Tags
5-star review, book review, book reviews, books, Deborah J. Brasket, editorial review, epic protest literature, fiction, keywords and categories, milestone celebration, novel about revolution, political thriller, Readers' Favorite, Romance, This Sea Within, wartime romance
When creating a book, because it’s such a long and arduous process, you have to celebrate every milestone, no matter how small. And winning 5 stars for my first professional editorial review is something to celebrate.
I hope you think so too! Here it is, shiny badge and all.
“Deborah J. Brasket’s This Sea Within is the story of Lena Landon, who is an aspiring photojournalist and a young American surfer. In 1971, she travels to San Balanque to explore her mother’s roots, and is drawn into a revolutionary movement that seems to reflect everything she has ever dreamed about and wanted to do.
She is still haunted by her mother’s abandonment, but the activism of her father inspires her. She becomes entangled with the Aguileros, a guerrilla faction led by Raoul Aguilero. From the start, it is curiosity for her, but her fight for freedom becomes a passionate commitment when she falls for Raoul. She trains as a soldier and undergoes dangerous undercover work by infiltrating the government, the same regime whose Vice President is married to her mother, Dolores Machado.
This is a story of political reckoning and is most suitable for those looking for well-written and epic protest literature.
The author writes brilliantly about romantic obsession, dividing the story into three parts that skillfully move from the stage of dreaming to commitment and conflict, and finally to an hour of blood that delivers a mesmerizing climax.
Deborah J. Brasket captivated me with the seductive allure of an idealism of a powerful revolution and how it connects with nuanced morality. The sea is a well-thought-out metaphor, rich in its destructive and creative forces, and it is cleverly used to mirror the tension in the heroine. This Sea Within features complex and revolutionary characters, exciting prose, and streams of consciousness that lay bare the psyche of the key characters.
Fans of The Red Sparrow trilogy by Jason Matthews and The Kite Runner by Khaled Hosseini will enjoy how this book explores the way personal passion becomes inseparable from the cataclysm of history.” Divine Zape, Readers’ Favorite 5 star review
Three things I loved that surprised me about this review:
- She referred to This Sea Within as “epic protest literature.” For some reason that surprised me. Deciding what genre this novel is was really difficult, and I still don’t know what to call it: 20th century historical fiction, coming of age novel, war story, love story, women’s adventure fiction, romantic suspense, political thriller . . . I suppose it’s one of those genre-bending novels. And there are so many of them. Here’s the key words and categories I chose for KDP publisher:
- 1970s historical fiction
- wartime romance
- novels about revolution
- Central American fiction
- romantic love stories
- new adult romance fiction
- hot steamy romance
- • Books › Literature & Fiction › Action & Adventure › Women’s Adventure ↗
- • Books › Literature & Fiction › Action & Adventure › Romance ↗
- • Books › Literature & Fiction › Women’s Fiction › Single Women ↗
I think I was stuck on thinking of this in a romance category, although this reviewer hardly mentions that aspect. The next category that came to mind for me was adventure story. The categories you can chose from are really restrictive. I used a software program designed to be used with Amazon that lets you know which category has the best chance to rise to the top of the page: some are more competitive than others.
I may be rethinking these keywords and categories before this goes to print. If you have any suggestions on which makes a good fit, I’d appreciate your thoughts.
2. I liked how how she referred to the titled three-part structure of This Sea Within that “moves from the stage of dreaming to commitment and conflict, and finally to an hour of blood.” That was deliberate: Hour of the Garden, Hour Up in Arms, Hour of Blood. Those part titles came from a poem by poet Pablo Neruda. I spent a lot of time on this, so it’s really validating when a reviewer takes notice.
Similarly, her mention of the sea metaphor: rich in its destructive and creative forces, and it is cleverly used to mirror the tension in the heroine. I loved how she got that too.
3. Her comparison of my novel to The Red Sparrow trilogy by Jason Matthews and The Kite Runner by Khaled Hosseini really blew me away too. I love those novels! But I never thought of my novel in the same category.
And then that last line: this book explores the way personal passion becomes inseparable from the cataclysm of history. Yes, I definitely was trying to do that with this novel but never thought of it in quite those eloquent terms.
All this is just to show that a writer can learn a lot about her own work when viewing in through the lens of the reader. We are co-creators really, each of us taking away different things from our writing and reading.
How cool is that? Something, indeed, worth celebrating.
This Sea Within is ready for pre-order in ebook on Amazon, and in print on Barnes and Noble and Bookshop. Book release is June 15.
Discover more from Deborah J. Brasket, Author
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.


Kudos Deborah. That is an insightful and in depth review. Your book is hard to fit in standard categories. It certainly has elements of romance, coming of age, adventure, revolution, and historical fiction.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Thanks Brad. I really am rethinking my categories. I just received two more editorial reviews that labeled this as a coming of age novel, while also highlighting the revolution and barely mentioning any romance.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Are you limited in how many categories to list?
LikeLike
Yes, only three categories and 7 keywords. Yet, this is what Amazon puts on my Sea Within page, emphasizing historical fiction when that’s not listed in my KDP categories and in only one of my 7 keywords! Go figure!
LikeLiked by 1 person
Congratulations for that excellent Readers’ Favorite 5-star review, Deborah!
LikeLiked by 1 person
Thanks, Tim!
LikeLiked by 1 person
My pleasure, Deborah. 😍
LikeLike
I would not pick up and read a book classified as war romance or romantic love story. I would most definitely read a book that is called epic protest literature. I haven’t read your book yet, so I can’t really say, but I would question the categories you are working with and whatever software program you used. I get that you want to move to the top of the Amazon list and that you want to sell as many books as possible, but maybe some rethinking is in order. I have no idea who the reviewer is, and reviews are subjective, but this review is intriguing.
LikeLike
I really appreciate your feedback on the categories and keywords, Valorie. I’m thinking I do need to change them.
The impetus was to write a steamy love story with depth and substance, so I set it during a revolution in Latin America so I could highlight the disastrous foreign policy below our border, propping up dictators that would allow the US pillage the countries resources.
I was looking to write something like the Outlander series which was also set during wartime, resistance fighters, and a revolution. Yet the love story between Claire and Jaimie was a major theme running through it, and contained some very steamy love scenes.
But two editorial reviews I received just today, call this a coming of age novel and highlight the civil unrest, fight for justice, and the revolution. Neither even mention the romance! Nor did another review I received recently from a fellow author, who labeled this a political thriller.
Taking a closer look at my novel, there are only 7 chapters out of 49 that focus (almost) exclusively on the romantic involvement of Lena and Raoul, and only 7 chapters that contain steamy love scenes. Although sprinkled throughout are romantic and sexy moments between these two characters. Much to think about!
LikeLiked by 2 people
And the final, final, really final episode in the Outlander 8 season series airs tomorrow night!!!! I’ll be sad.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Me too! Although I have to wait until it plays on Netflix to view.
LikeLike
Congratulations! Your novel is in a league of its own. I love how you named sections from a Pablo Neruda poem. Wow.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Thanks, Ka. I love Neruda’s poetry! I wish I could have quoted from that poem, but I would have needed to get permission to do so and pay a fee no doubt. Still, I borrowed a couple of phrases. It’s a poem about a revolution and starts out:
Right Comrade, It’s the hour of the garden
and the hour up in arms, each day
follows from flower or blood:
LikeLike
So excited for you…thrilled about the recognition. I’m enjoying “This Sea Within” and find myself slowing down to savor, vs. clipping along at my normal reading speed. The pace, the characters, the storyline…giving this reader a languid reminder to savor. Cheers to you, Deborah! 💝💝💝
LikeLiked by 1 person
I’m so glad you are enjoying it, Vicki! No hurry. Savor as much as you want!
LikeLiked by 1 person
I am…I am! Like rationing chapters, LOL!
❤️😉❤️
LikeLike
Congratulations!
LikeLiked by 1 person
Thanks, Dawn!
LikeLike